--- title: "Labor-Management Relations at BART: Weathering a Storm of Their Own Making" description: "Labor-Management Relations at BART: Weathering a Storm of Their Own Making" --- ![Overland Resource Group](https://www.orginc.com/hs-fs/hubfs/ORG_2017_Q1/ORG.jpg?t=1483128475379&width=215&name=ORG.jpg "Overland Resource Group") For full functionality of this site it is necessary to **enable JavaScript**. Here are the [instructions how to enable JavaScript in your web browser](http://www.enable-javascript.com/). - [Login](https://org.mocaworks.com/logon/) - [913.829.1241](tel:9138291241) [![ORG_Brand_Logo_215x102-01.png](https://www.orginc.com/hs-fs/hubfs/ORG_2017_Q1/ORG_Brand_Logo_215x102-01.png?width=215&height=102&name=ORG_Brand_Logo_215x102-01.png "ORG_Brand_Logo_215x102-01.png")](https://orginc-2633051-hs-sites-com.sandbox.hs-sites.com/) - [What We Do](https://www.orginc.com/what-we-do) - [Organizations](https://www.orginc.com/organization) - [Organizations + Unions](https://www.orginc.com/organizations-unions) - [Case Studies](https://www.orginc.com/case-studies) - [Who We Are](https://www.orginc.com/who-we-are) - [Blog](https://www.orginc.com/blog) - [Podcasts](https://www.orginc.com/podcasts) - [Careers](https://www.orginc.com/careers) - [Contact Us](https://www.orginc.com/contact-us) # ORG Blog ## Labor-Management Relations at BART: Weathering a Storm of Their Own Making by [Cathy Wright](https://www.orginc.com/blog/author/cwright), on November 29, 2013 [![danger thin ice](https://www.orginc.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/danger-thin-ice-e1385736044143.jpg?width=250&height=167&name=danger-thin-ice-e1385736044143.jpg)](https://www.orginc.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/danger-thin-ice-e1385736044143.jpg)We didn’t want to be right. In the Autumn edition of [\\org\\ INK](http://us6.campaign-archive2.com/?u=42cab228467e4c8798c99c44e&id=9de5dd6642&e=c7b48a5089), Overland’s e-newsletter, we included a Fall Forecast that predicted “**Stormy Times Ahead for BART, SEIU & Amalgamated Transit Union.”** And even as we asserted that the parties would eventually reach a contractual agreement (despite seven months of tortured negotiations, two strikes and a governor-mandated cooling off period), we called for them to resist the automatic reaction to return to status quo and instead get busy pursuing a different path that would enable them to work together *between* contract negotiations to find creative solutions to the problems dividing them. Now, due to the state of labor-management relations at BART, the parties will have to weather a storm of their own making. Little could we have imagined that just days after union members ratified the contract, another dispute of epic proportions would erupt, immediately sending labor and management back to their respective corners, ready to come out swinging. And swing they have. On Nov. 21, the BART board voted to officially reject a family leave provision in the union-ratified contract, calling the inclusion of the provision accidental, and noting that at an estimated cost of between $5.8 and $44.2 million, the agency could not afford to live with the mistake.  The unions cried foul and set off speculation about whether the 200,000 San Francisco Bay area commuters would again have to endure a strike. As the unions consider their options, it is clear to us that the parties are back to business as usual, and sadly that is continuing toward what looks to be building into full-blown [intractable conflict](https://www.orginc.com/blog/2012/12/27/intractable-conflict-at-hostess-brands). In such cases, the parties are more interested in their side “winning,” shaming the other side, pointing fingers and blaming. If, on the other hand, the parties had taken a more constructive approach long before the whole negotiation debacle began and worked at building professional, mutually-beneficial relationships, they would be better positioned to sort through this conflict. They would be seeking a middle ground solution that would balance BART’s fiscal realities with the union’s obligation to secure favorable wages and  benefits for its members, while enabling both parties to signal their respect for the collective bargaining processes they have agreed to. Above all, they’d be much closer to getting back to focusing on the real business of providing service to the commuters who rely on them. Unfortunately, looking at the current climate, our Winter forecast calls for a protracted cold spell, with sporadic heated debate, deep-seated conflict and legal wrangling, producing continuing uncertain conditions contributing to growing dissatisfaction from employees and customers. This will leave in its wake damaged reputations for the unions and BART management and increasingly strained relations between the two.  Only with leadership, and recognition that pursuing a different path is the only sensible choice, will a Spring thaw and the opportunity to rebuild become possible. Anyone see it differently? We welcome your comments. *Cathy Wright is a partner and Vice-President at Overland Resource Group, which has 30 years of experience helping organizations improve operational performance and quality of work life through increased employee engagement and labor-management collaboration. She can be reached at c.wright@orginc.com.* Topics: [Conflict Resolution](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/conflict-resolution-2) [Labor Management](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/labor-management) [Leadership](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/leadership) - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) [![New Call-to-action](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/2633051/fcb6e8cf-0376-4788-8ae8-c5c775f2fc4b.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/2633051/fcb6e8cf-0376-4788-8ae8-c5c775f2fc4b) ### Subscribe to Email Updates ### Recent Posts ### Posts by Topic - [Collaboration (55)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/collaboration) - [Labor Management (46)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/labor-management) - [Leadership (44)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/leadership) - [Sustainable Change (21)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/sustainable-change) - [Conflict Resolution (16)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/conflict-resolution-2) - [Employee Engagement (14)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/employee-engagement) - [Overland Resource Group (13)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/overland-resource-group) - [Breakthrough (5)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/breakthrough) - [7 Levers of Sustainable Performance (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/7-levers-of-sustainable-performance) - [Coaching (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/coaching) - [Productivity (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/productivity) - [Company Culture (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/company-culture) - [Intractable Conflict (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/intractable-conflict) - [Organizational Transformation (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/topic/organizational-transformation) see all ### Blog Archive - [April 2019 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2019/04) - [March 2019 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2019/03) - [February 2019 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2019/02) - [January 2019 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2019/01) - [December 2018 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2018/12) - [November 2018 (3)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2018/11) - [September 2018 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2018/09) - [August 2018 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2018/08) - [May 2018 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2018/05) - [March 2018 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2018/03) - [February 2018 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2018/02) - [January 2018 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2018/01) - [December 2017 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2017/12) - [November 2017 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2017/11) - [October 2017 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2017/10) - [July 2017 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2017/07) - [June 2017 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2017/06) - [May 2017 (3)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2017/05) - [April 2017 (3)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2017/04) - [March 2017 (3)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2017/03) - [April 2016 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2016/04) - [March 2016 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2016/03) - [February 2016 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2016/02) - [October 2015 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2015/10) - [June 2015 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2015/06) - [May 2015 (5)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2015/05) - [December 2014 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2014/12) - [October 2014 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2014/10) - [August 2014 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2014/08) - [June 2014 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2014/06) - [May 2014 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2014/05) - [April 2014 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2014/04) - [March 2014 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2014/03) - [February 2014 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2014/02) - [November 2013 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2013/11) - [October 2013 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2013/10) - [September 2013 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2013/09) - [August 2013 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2013/08) - [July 2013 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2013/07) - [May 2013 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2013/05) - [April 2013 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2013/04) - [January 2013 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2013/01) - [December 2012 (4)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2012/12) - [November 2012 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2012/11) - [August 2012 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2012/08) - [July 2012 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2012/07) - [June 2012 (2)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2012/06) - [February 2012 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2012/02) - [December 2011 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2011/12) - [August 2011 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2011/08) - [July 2011 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2011/07) - [June 2011 (1)](https://www.orginc.com/blog/archive/2011/06) see all ### Overland Resource Group PO Box 23592 Overland Park, KS 66283 [913-829-1241](tel:+9138291241) 866-691-0770 ### From Our Blog ### Let's Connect ### Subscribe to Newsletter © 2026 Overland Resource Group, INC. [Privacy Policy](https://www.orginc.com/privacy-policy) Website By[Tank New Media](https://www.tanknewmedia.com) ![](https://dc.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=164868&fmt=gif)